Avoiding the Most Common Pitfall of Customer Journey Mapping

How to the Most Common Pitfall of Customer Journey Mapping

Gaining a better understanding of customers through journey mapping has become an entrusted strategy for organisations seeking to improve their relationships and service. As CEO of Scandinavian Airlines, Jan Carlzon transformed his company and the hundreds of firms that followed his lead by introducing the importance of identifying and addressing what he called Moments of Truth. Carlzon and his followers insisted that success was created through each ‘memorable Customer Experience’ – experiences that would engender customer goodwill, brand loyalty and flawless corporate reputation. His seminal work (dating back to the 80s) provoked the creation of an entirely new school of thought that has inspired breakthrough innovations in customer relationship management for nearly 40 years.

Interest in this methodology and others like it has endured the test of time. After all, how could anyone argue against the theory that how customers interact with an organization is the most worthwhile indicator with which to understand their overall level of satisfaction? And yet customer service is a continuous source of complaint and organisations routinely fail to attain the results they envision. What could have possibly gone so wrong?

Perhaps it’s because those efforts began from the wrong starting position. In recent years, Carlzon and other theorists have acknowledged the missing ingredient from their original recipe: a comprehensive understanding of Customer Expectations. We agree with their assessment. The only real way to define ‘good service’ is with the knowledge of what the customer expected in the first place compared to their actual experience. Unfortunately, commonplace customer research typically skirts the idea of expectations; instead leaving it up to chance or, worse, the inherently biased guesswork of far removed MDs and executives.

Millions have been spent (or rather, wasted) on quick fixes and suboptimal data points. It would seem that companies would rather bypass intuitive customer feedback in favour of generic satisfaction surveys that yield few insights of any discernible depth. But if the Customer Experience is going to substantially improve as it is so desperately crying out for, it will be solely reliant on a shift of focus from vague platitudes like ‘customer satisfaction’ to the much more concrete and measurable Customer Expectations.

When utilised as a measure, Customers Expectations provide actionable insights; shedding light on the things that your customers deem most important to them and moving beyond the unintuitive data mining of yesteryear. Only then will you truly understand your customers’ journeys and the basis upon which they are judging the impact of those ‘moments of truth.’

So, what are Customer Expectations?

‘Customer Expectations’ is a commonplace term and one that nearly everyone understands; at least at surface level. It’s so commonplace, in fact, that we tend to take its meaning for granted. Customer Expectations cannot simply be defined on each customers’ behalf — rather it is up to them to decide for themselves. Of course, that means that such information isn’t given up readily, and is certainly beyond the capabilities of the likes of the Net Promoter Score (NPS) to capture.

One type of ‘expectation’ is a prediction. For example, if I have consistently bad experiences with one provider, I might reasonably expect that my next experience will also be lacking. Another kind is what is called an ‘ideal expectation.’ In this sense, an expectation is a desired state. It defines the ideal attributes of a product, service, transaction or relationship as desired by the customer. The ideal is where we focus our attention as it provides the most useful baseline for success.

Using the methodology developed by our partners at Promising Outcomes, we learn the extent to which the actual Customer Experience compares to their ideal expectations. The heart of the theory is that — to a significant degree — customer judgments, motivations and actions are influenced by perceptions of how well the provider has performed to their ideal expectations. Years of research and testing has enabled Promising Outcomes to develop reliable processes and tools to make those ideal expectations explicit and clear. Then, by aspiring to reach the ideal as a target, organisations can set meaningful goals for delivery and performance.

Here’s how that process stands to benefit any company that uses it:

• Measuring Customer Expectations and subsequently performance against them is the very goal of CX strategies, yet very few companies actually measure performance in this way. Thus, a competitor that did happen to utilise such a method stands to gain a significant competitive advantage.
• The benefit to the organization is that it is using concrete customer data to direct improvement, not the best guesstimates of internal advocates. They are using data to make good investment decisions. As Roger Milliken famously said: “in God we trust, everyone else brings data!”
• Accurate areas for improvement, and their priority level, can be precisely identified. Very few (if any) other methods can make this claim.
• The data tells the truth. For some organisations this can be hard to stomach, but it remains vital if you want to commit to better customer relationships.
• The organization can also understand how well it performs compared to competitors. This gives CEOs an unprecedented opportunity to differentiate. For public organisations, they are still competing with the standards set by customers’ perceptions of other industries.
• Organisations that constantly seek customer-driven improvement are, ironically, far more successful or profitable than those that are primarily driven by finance.

Ultimately, it’s clear that Customer Journey Maps are best developed on a solid foundation of robust expectations that capture the authentic voice of the customer. Expectations gathering and mapping is the first step in developing highly focused, customer-friendly survey and diagnostic instruments that provide actionable data; for prioritising improvements that truly make a difference to your customers; and for creating memorable Customer Experiences that turn your customers into loyal brand advocates. But the biggest payoff is a deeper understanding of your customers — profound knowledge that can point the way to organisational success.

Article by: Peg Anthony 

Explore Expectation-Based Insights for Your Organisation